Do companies switch to better software?

When a company completes a move between two tools that do the same job, other companies rate the tool it chose about 0.4 points higher, on a 10-point scale, than the tool it left. The tool left typically sits below its category's average rating and the tool chosen about 0.2 above it. Smaller companies choose tools further above their category average; at 1,000 employees and above, the tool chosen sits close to the average, though it still rates above the tool left. The tool chosen usually serves smaller companies than the one left.

Based on verified interviews with the marketing, ecommerce, data and technology leaders deciding whether to replace a tool, and with what, at DTC and enterprise brands. Buyers are anonymized before publication; vendor names and views are reported as given. No vendor paid to appear or could edit this page.

+0.4
How much higher other companies rate the tool a switcher chose than the tool it left, on a 10-point scale, across completed moves between tools that do the same job.
About half
Of that gap is the tool left sitting below its category's average rating. The tool chosen sits about 0.2 above that average.
Under half
In the typical move, the tool chosen's typical customer, by employee count, as a share of the tool left's. It compares the two tools' customers, not the size of the company switching.
Tool left Tool chosen Zero = the category's average rating

Each dot is how other companies rate that tool, in points on a 10-point scale above or below the average rating in the same category. The rows split completed moves by the employee count of the company that moved; the three size rows do not overlap and together make up the top row, less the moves whose company has no size on record. Each row rests on several dozen moves or more, and a company that made two moves counts in a row twice. Figures are rounded.

Do companies that switch software end up with a better-rated tool?

On average, yes, and the margin is modest. Across completed moves in Alium's buyer interviews, where a company replaced one tool with another that does the same job, other companies rate the tool it chose about 0.4 points higher than the tool it left. About half of moves land on a tool rated at least 0.3 higher; about one in seven land on one rated at least 0.3 lower, and the rest are within 0.3 either way. Those shares are of completed moves, not of companies or of everyone who uses either tool, and they are not churn rates for any vendor.

The 0.4 is the less interesting half of the result. A company that leaves a tool has usually found something wrong with it, so the tools left behind are not a fair sample of their categories, and beating them is a low bar. The question that matters to someone choosing a replacement is whether switchers land on tools that are good for their category, or only better than what they had. Some of both, and the part above the category average is concentrated: leaving out the most common destination in each category cuts it to under 0.1.

What counts as a move here

Each term below is measured on its own, and none of them overlaps another.

Completed move
An interview records that the company stopped using one named tool for a job and now uses another named tool for that same job. A move counts only when both tools are named and the replacement is described as complete. Planned changes, moves still underway, a tool dropped with nothing named in its place, a move to an in-house build and a move at the buyer's previous employer do not count. These are histories as buyers report them, not audited migrations.
Tool left and tool chosen
The two ends of one completed move. A company counts once for each pair of tools, however many interviews discuss it, and a company that reports separate moves can contribute more than one pair.
The category average
The average of the individual ratings in that category, such as email platforms or helpdesks, leaving out ratings from the company that moved; the ratings for the tool left and the tool chosen leave that company out too. Each rating counts equally, so tools with more ratings weigh more. It is the average rating in the interviewed sample, not an average of tools weighted equally or of a random installation.
A tool's typical customer
The middle company size, by employee count from the company record, among the other interviewed companies whose stack includes that tool.

How much of the gain is just leaving a weak tool?

About half. Compared with its category's average rating, the tool a company leaves sits about 0.2 points below it, and the tool it chooses about 0.2 above it. So the gap between old and new is roughly an equal split: companies leave weaker tools, and they pick tools rated above their category average.

The destination's premium of about 0.2 over its category average deserves scrutiny, because rating habits, suite modules, ratings from recent switchers and concentration among popular destinations could each produce some of it. The checks below test those one at a time, and passing them does not show that switchers consistently pick objectively better tools. Some buyers rate everything generously, so a tool whose raters happen to be generous would look better; adjusting every rating for its buyer's rating habits leaves the destination about 0.2 above its category average. Suite modules rate lower than standalone tools in most categories, as the suite-or-specialist page shows, so moves off a suite could be doing the work; with every suite module removed from both ends, the destination still sits about 0.2 above. A tool's ratings could also be lifted by switchers' own ratings, from the companies that just moved onto it; removing those companies from every tool's ratings leaves the destination about 0.2 above, too.

The strongest qualification is concentration among popular destinations. Email and ecommerce platforms carry a large share of the moves; leave them out and the destination sits about 0.1 above its category average, and the gap between old and new narrows to about 0.2. Leave out each category's single most common destination instead and the premium falls under 0.1, while the gap between old and new stays about 0.3, because the tools left still sit below their category average. The most common destinations are familiar names, with Klaviyo, Shopify and Braze among the most prominent. A substantial share of the above-average premium comes from repeated moves toward a small set of well-rated tools, and it is not evidence that switchers in every category consistently choose above-average alternatives.

The premium appears in most categories with enough moves to examine, but its size varies. BI and reporting tools are the notable exception: there, in a relatively small group of moves, the tool chosen was not rated above its category average. The Tableau alternatives page finds the same thing from the other end, in where companies leaving one BI tool go. Between those category differences and the concentration above, the 0.4 gap should not be read as the expected result of a switch in every market.

This is the average buyer's picture. What does your stack need?A free, peer-powered checkup returns a shortlist for your stack and your next steps.
Start my checkup →

Do switchers move to tools built for companies their size?

Usually toward smaller ones. In the typical move, the tool chosen has a typical customer less than half the size of the tool left's, and in about seven moves in ten its typical customer is the smaller of the two. That describes the two tools' customer populations; it does not mean the company that moved got smaller, and it does not show the tool was chosen because it serves smaller companies.

Whether that is right-sizing depends on what a company's tools usually look like, because most tools in these interviews serve companies larger than the buyer describing them. So the comparison here is with the rest of the mover's own stack, measured the same way. Against that, the tool left typically served companies about a third larger than the mover's other tools did, and the tool chosen companies a little over half the size. Compared with the rest of the switcher's stack, then, the tool chosen generally serves smaller companies, and the tool left often serves larger ones, especially for switchers under 1,000 employees. That fits some smaller companies moving away from tools associated with larger organizations; it does not make the tool chosen the closer size match in every case, especially at large switchers.

The typical customer of the tool left and of the tool chosen, each as a multiple of the typical customer of the mover's other tools, by the size of the company that moved. Above 1 means the tool serves larger companies than the rest of that company's stack does. Figures are rounded typical values, not ranges.
Company that moved Tool left Tool chosen
Under 200 employees about 2×about 0.6×
200 to 999 about 1.6×about 0.6×
1,000 and above about 0.8×about 0.6×
All moves about 1.3×about 0.6×

Across all three bands, the tool chosen serves companies about 0.6 times the typical size of those the switcher's other tools serve. Under 200 employees, the tool left sits at about 2 times against 0.6 for the tool chosen; at 200 to 999, about 1.6 against 0.6. At 1,000 and above, both tools serve smaller companies than the rest of the stack, and the tool left, at about 0.8, is closer to that benchmark than the tool chosen. So the shift toward tools with smaller typical customers is consistent, but the tool chosen is not always the closer match.

After moving its SMS program to Postscript, partly on price, this buyer valued that the vendor builds the work as well as advising on it: “Because I have a very lean team of only one person, they're very hands-on in terms of executing on building new flows and building new campaigns.” VP, Customer Strategy and Analytics · DTC beverage brand · Oct 2025

Where does the rating advantage appear?

The tool chosen sits furthest above its category average at smaller companies and in moves toward tools with smaller typical customers. That does not mean other groups see no difference between the tool they leave and the one they choose, only that their destinations sit closer to the category average. Where the tool chosen serves smaller companies than the tool left, it sits about 0.3 above its category average; where it serves companies the same size or larger, it sits about level with the average. The association is smaller, but still there, when email and ecommerce platforms or each category's most common destination are left out.

It is an association, and it does not show that choosing a tool with smaller customers produces a better result; the mix of categories, popular destinations and differences between the companies making these moves may all contribute. The customer-size shift and the destination premium appear together, especially at smaller switchers, and the interviews do not show whether one explains the other or whether both track the same tools, categories or circumstances.

The same split shows up by the size of the company moving, as the chart at the top of the page draws. Companies under 200 employees choose tools about 0.36 above their category average; companies of 200 to 999, about 0.18; companies of 1,000 and above, about 0.06, which is little premium over the average rather than no improvement over the tool left. In all three bands the tool left sits below its category average, so the gap between old and new is still about 0.5, 0.4 and 0.3 in turn. The difference is that smaller companies, on average, choose tools noticeably above the category average, and larger ones choose tools close to it.

The interviews do not say why. One possible explanation, ours rather than one buyers give, is that larger companies have fewer suitable alternatives for complex or high-volume work, consistent with how company size shapes the stack. Another is that their moves more often reflect centralization, consolidation or organizational decisions than a search for a higher-rated tool, which the great consolidation describes. Neither is established: the interviews do not record each buyer's full set of options or how much each motive weighed.

After a sunset tool and an intermediate replacement, this team moved its testing to Shoplift, which it describes as “a solution that is Shopify certified and built for Shopify”. Vice President, Ecommerce · multi-brand apparel company · Oct 2025

The counter-current: buyers rarely say size was the reason

The size pattern is in the company records far more than in what buyers say. Remarks such as more than we needed or built for enterprise come up in fewer than one in ten interviews with a completed move, only a little more often than in interviews without one. So the size shift may be a by-product of other reasons for moving rather than something switchers set out to find, and a buyer should not read the table above as a rule others follow deliberately.

What this means if you are planning a switch

Our recommendations, implications of the pattern above rather than a process buyers describe. The tools companies chose are rated somewhat higher by other companies than the tools they left; that does not measure how much the company that moved benefited, or whether the migration justified its cost. Five questions, each of which only you can answer:

Want this checked against your own stack?

Start my checkup →

What not to read into this

That switching makes buyers happier. Every rating here comes from other companies, never from the company that moved, so a higher-rated destination means other buyers rate it more highly. It is not a before-and-after measure of anyone's satisfaction, and two different groups of raters are not one company's experience changing. The interviews do not record whether a move paid off for the company that made it.

That better ratings cause switches, or the reverse. Switchers may pick tools because they rate well, well-rated tools may simply be the ones most switchers hear about, or both may follow from something else. This is an association across completed moves, not a cause.

That the size shift is a strategy. The size figures come from company records, not from what buyers said they wanted, and buyers rarely name size as the reason. A tool's typical customer is a middle value across companies that vary widely, so a single tool can serve companies of any size well.

That these are all the moves. A move counts only where the buyer describes both ends in one interview, so moves the interview did not reach are missing, and this is not a count of how often companies switch. The moves come from the companies Alium happened to interview, which are not a random sample of any vendor's customers.

Common questions

Do companies that switch software end up with a better-rated tool?

On average, yes, by a modest margin. Across completed moves between tools that do the same job, other companies rate the tool a switcher chose about 0.4 points higher, on a 10-point scale, than the tool it left. About half of moves land on a tool rated at least 0.3 higher and about one in seven on one rated at least 0.3 lower. The ratings come from other companies, not from the switcher, so this compares the two tools' reputations rather than measuring whether the move made anyone happier.

Is the new software actually better, or was the old software just bad?

Both, in roughly equal parts. Compared with the average rating in the same category, the tool companies leave sits about 0.2 points below it and the tool they choose about 0.2 above it. So about half of the gap between old and new is simply that companies leave weaker tools. The other half is that they pick tools rated above their category average. That half holds after adjusting for how generously each buyer rates and after removing suite modules, but it is concentrated: leaving out each category's most common destination cuts it to under 0.1.

Do companies switch to software built for smaller companies?

Usually. In the typical move, the tool chosen has a typical customer less than half the size of the tool left's, measured by employee count, and in about seven moves in ten the tool chosen has the smaller typical customer. That compares the two tools' customers, not the switcher's size. Below 1,000 employees, the tool left typically served larger companies than the switcher's other tools did. At 1,000 employees and above it did not, and both tools served smaller companies than the rest of the stack, so the tool chosen is not always the closer match.

Does switching software make buyers more satisfied?

This page cannot say. Every rating here comes from other companies, so a higher-rated destination means other buyers rate the new tool more highly, not that the company that moved is happier than it was. The interviews also do not record whether a move paid off for the company that made it, what it cost, or whether a better-rated tool attracted the switcher or the switch is what led to it.

How can you tell whether a replacement tool is an upgrade?

Our recommendation, not a practice buyers describe, is to test a replacement against more than the tool you have. Check how your current tool compares with its category average, because beating a weak incumbent is a low bar; check whether a candidate's ratings come from companies like yours; name the improvement that would justify the migration, because an average gap in peer ratings is not an estimate of it; and, at a large company, look for evidence from organizations with comparable needs, because there the tools chosen sit only slightly above their category average. Who signs off, and what the old tool still supports, decide the rest.

For moves that fold several tools into one, see the great consolidation; for how suite modules rate against standalone tools, suite or specialist; for which tools each size of company runs, how company size shapes the stack; and for the tools companies keep despite low ratings, why buyers keep software they rate poorly.

Get a checkup on your tech stack

A checkup for your marketing stack, built from hundreds of verified buyer interviews: what matters most to you, a shortlist for your stack, and your next steps.

Start my checkup

Free · no password · your answers are anonymized before they inform research like this.

Want to come back to this?We'll email you a link to this page, so it's easy to find later or forward to your team.
Methodology. Alium conducts verified interviews with software buyers — the marketing, ecommerce, data and technology leaders who select and operate these platforms. A move on this page is a tool a buyer's company stopped using for a job and a tool it now uses for the same job, both named in the same interview. Candidate moves were found automatically and then read by hand in the buyer's own words: a move counts only where the buyer describes the company replacing one with the other, the replacement is live, and the two tools do the same job, which removed a large share of the automatic matches. A sample of the hand reading was checked again and agreed. Moves the buyer describes at a previous employer, moves to an in-house build or to no tool, partial moves and moves still underway are left out, and each company counts once per pair of tools. Ratings for both tools come from other companies only: the moving company's own ratings never count toward either side. A tool is compared only where it has at least eight ratings from other companies. The category average is the mean of every individual rating in that category from companies other than the mover, so tools with more ratings count for more. A tool's typical customer is the middle company size, by employee count from the company record, among the other interviewed companies whose stack includes it; the mover's own other tools are measured the same way. Gaps were checked after adjusting each rating for how generously its buyer rates everything else, after removing suite modules, after removing email and ecommerce platforms, after removing each category's most common destination, and after removing the companies known to have moved onto each tool from its ratings. The link between moves toward tools with smaller typical customers and higher destination ratings was rechecked with email and ecommerce platforms left out, and again with each category's most common destination left out. Duplicate product records are merged before counting. Buyer identities are verified at interview time and anonymized before publication; vendor names are reported as given. No vendor paid to appear or was able to edit this page.