Manufacturers are a large share of the buyers who discuss product information management in these interviews, and they are not one buyer. A snack maker shipping to Walmart and a tools maker selling through industrial distributors both call their system a PIM, and both need it to hold specifications and push content out. What differs is where the content goes, and that decides what they buy. This page compares manufacturers with the consumer brands and retailers in the same interviews, so the needs that are genuinely theirs stand apart from the ones every PIM buyer has. The ratings table and the pre-purchase lessons live on what PIM buyers wish they’d known.
Which PIM system should a manufacturer use?
The interviews point to a fork, not a single product: first ask who sells your products, then what they need from you. A manufacturer whose goods reach shoppers through Amazon, Walmart and Target needs reliable product data and a way to deliver it in the formats and processes each retailer accepts, so syndication coverage weighs alongside how well the PIM keeps the data itself. Some consumer-goods makers here chose Salsify partly for the retailers it reaches, and others use Salsify and Syndigo together because different retailers accept different networks. Distribution shapes the purchase; it does not mean the PIM and the syndication network must come from one provider. A manufacturer that also sells through distributors and dealers, prints catalogs or carries thousands of configurable parts is choosing for jobs most retail-focused PIMs treat as secondary, and that group spreads across more vendors. Neither path is about ERP integration or technical specifications as such: both come up among brands and retailers about as often as among manufacturers.
Three cautions on the shares above. They count companies that rate a PIM in an interview, which is not the same as the companies that use one, and a company can rate two. The split between consumer-goods and industrial makers comes from company records about what each company makes, not from the buyers. And Salsify’s prominence shows which PIMs these manufacturers rate and discuss, not which they bought most recently, whether they run it alone, or which suits manufacturers best: the sections below show where it does not fit.
How do manufacturers choose a PIM differently from brands and retailers?
Mostly on two things: where the content has to go, and whether a B2B channel sits beside the retail one. The table sorts the PIM jobs buyers bring up by what their company makes and how it sells, and it shows how often each job comes up, not how many companies need it. The first row is where manufacturers differ most from everyone else; the last two, technical attributes and ERP or PLM integration, come up across buyer types rather than among manufacturers alone.
| Job the PIM is asked to do | Industrial and durable-goods makers | Consumer-goods makers | Consumer brands | Retailers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Send content to retailers and marketplaces | About a third | About three in five | About one in five | About one in ten; more often receiving supplier content |
| Feed distributors, dealers or wholesale accounts | About one in eight | About one in eight, mostly bottlers and drinks distributors | About one in ten, as wholesale accounts | None |
| Build B2B, sales or print catalogs | A few | Almost none | Almost none | Almost none |
| Handle large SKU counts or deep variants | About one in six | About one in ten | Almost none | About one in ten |
| Hold technical, compliance or regulatory attributes | About one in six | About one in five | About one in fourteen | About one in six |
| Integrate with the ERP or PLM | About one in seven | About one in ten | About one in seven | About one in ten |
Two readings of the table. B2B work comes up in a minority of industrial and durable-goods makers: about one in eight raise distributor or dealer feeds and a few raise B2B, sales or print catalogs, and some raise both. Those jobs help explain why that group’s vendor list is wider; they do not show how many industrial manufacturers need them. And technical attributes are not the manufacturer’s problem alone: retailers raise them as often, usually as supplier data arriving incomplete, and consumer-goods makers raise them as nutrition panels, weights and barcodes. A beauty retailer hopes its new PIM “will allow the vendors to do the uploading,” so its team can send back a scorecard of what is missing. That is the same attribute problem, seen from the other end of the shelf.
What consumer-goods manufacturers need from a PIM: retailer reach
For a maker selling through large retailers, much of a PIM’s value is getting complete, accurate content into each retailer’s required workflow, so buyers weigh its syndication connections alongside its data capabilities. A global wine company that went with Salsify says what sold it was “that we have a good number of very large retail partners globally where that’s the only syndication that they allow for,” so buying a different PIM would still have meant signing up for Salsify’s syndication. A global healthcare group’s consumer business sets its bar the same way: a replacement “needs to encompass 90% of our e-commerce sales retailers,” with a roadmap for the rest. A global food maker describes the chain end to end: SAP is “the primary data source for our supply chain that feeds our Salsify PIM, which in turn feeds our syndication of content, written content, weights, measures,” and from there the retailers’ product pages.
Because retailers differ in the networks, formats and submission processes they accept, some makers use more than one syndication service, which need not mean two complete PIM implementations. A global food-and-beverage maker uses Salsify for convenience and smaller retailers and Syndigo for large-format ones: “As a general comment, Syndigo is more for large format, and Salsify is for small format.” Distribution adds a layer for some: a global beverage company rolling Salsify out across its bottling system says the missing part is getting from the brand PIM “to bottler team to customer PIM.” What consumer-goods makers rarely raise is anything B2B. Catalogs for a sales force and feeds to dealers barely appear, which is the clearest line between them and the industrial makers below.
What industrial and B2B manufacturers need from a PIM
Three jobs, and each pulls the choice somewhere different: feeds to distributors and dealers, catalogs, and the depth of the product model. These come up in a minority of industrial and durable-goods makers, but they are the reason that group’s vendor list is wide.
Distributor and dealer feeds. A global industrial-equipment manufacturer whose product data lives in a custom build inside its ecommerce platform is preparing an RFP for an API-driven PIM, “being able to share with dealers, with distributors, partners across the world, because today everything is a manual process.” It is a business-led requirement, “led by the need for our distributor network to really have access to our data,” and was in requirements gathering at the interview, so no vendor had been chosen. A home-comfort equipment maker that runs Salsify sends data both to Amazon and to its trade distribution customers, and its top goal is direct API connections to the big distributors “rather than filling out spreadsheets.” A technology-hardware maker on Akeneo credits it with “good syndication with our distributors.” A sporting-goods manufacturer went further and is building its PIM, DAM, customer data and “sales and dealer portals” on Pimcore, selected because of previous experience with it. As of November 2026 Pimcore’s site lists dealer and partner self-service portals among its uses, and its Community Edition is under the Pimcore Open Core License rather than a conventional open-source one, free for non-production use and for companies below a revenue threshold.
That is a completed replacement by a small manufacturer, and one company’s view of where Salsify fits. Catsy’s own site, checked in November 2026, describes it as purpose-built for manufacturers, B2B brands and wholesale distributors, including complex spec sheets and multi-variant SKUs. Salsify, for its part, publishes a page for B2B manufacturers, so the line the buyer draws is a reputation in this corpus rather than a product boundary.
| PIM | Rating | What manufacturers here chose it for |
|---|---|---|
| 7.6 | Retailer reach; for one maker, trade distribution customers and sales catalogs as well. | |
| around 7.5 | Depth of variants; connectors to marketplaces and retail partners; distributor syndication. | |
| not rated | Too few buyers rated it to publish a number. Low cost and ease of use, alongside an existing ERP and PLM. | |
| around 7 | Governance across subsidiaries and catalog publishing, in one tools maker’s evaluation. | |
| around 6.5 | Complex, multi-market catalogs, at a higher technical lift. | |
| not rated | B2B focus and price, replacing Salsify at a small industrial maker. Too few buyers rate it to publish a figure. | |
| not rated | One framework for PIM, DAM and dealer portals. Too few buyers rate it to publish a figure. |
Catalogs. A tools manufacturer selling through distributors and home-improvement retailers says its current PIM “falls short” in “its ability to go from PIM to print,” because refreshing catalog pages through InDesign is slow. It sent a detailed RFP to five vendors and favored Stibo Systems, which it judged one of the few that integrated well with InDesign, as well as stronger on data governance across its subsidiaries; Stibo’s own site, checked in November 2026, presents the product as multidomain master data management and does not lead with print. On the other side, a building-products maker uses Salsify to build custom catalogs from its data feeds that “really support our sales team,” so customers can import the information into their own sites. Catalogs are a criterion that some buyers find Salsify meets and others do not, rather than a gap in one product.
Variants and catalog depth. A furniture manufacturing group evaluating Akeneo names “The depth of variants” as the reason: “We have a very large variant set, and they have really deep options.” Akeneo’s documentation, checked in November 2026, models variants as up to two levels of product model above the variant product, so up to three levels of enrichment. A global home-products manufacturer that has used both Salsify and Inriver points to the same complexity when it rates Inriver higher for complex cases, citing regions, markets, translations and discontinuations, and adds that “with manufacturers in general it becomes a little bit complex,” with companies that carry “a lot, a lot of SKUs.” The other side of depth is effort: a multi-brand equipment manufacturer weighing Salsify against Inriver leans to Salsify “just because there’s a lower technical lift,” saying Inriver “requires a lot of technical resources” that would raise the total cost of ownership. That choice was still open at the interview.
Does a manufacturer’s PIM need to integrate with ERP and PLM?
Many manufacturers’ PIMs exchange data with an ERP, but in these interviews the ERP matters more for timing than for vendor choice. It is not the only source either: product data also comes from PLM and engineering systems, suppliers and commerce platforms. ERP and PLM integration comes up about as often among consumer brands as among industrial manufacturers, so it is not what separates manufacturers. Where it does shape a manufacturer’s decision, it does so by setting the date or the shape of the purchase. The home-comfort maker on Salsify says its homegrown ERP “does limit what I can do with the PIM until they decide to do a major ERP project.” An industrial-chemicals producer planned to adopt DynamicWeb as its “CMS, PIM, e-com platform” alongside an ERP rebuild on Dynamics 365, citing “a native integration with Microsoft ERP”; the migration was not finished at the interview. DynamicWeb’s parent company relaunched in January 2026 as Truvio, one brand for its Microsoft Dynamics software, and Truvio’s site, checked in November 2026, still labels its ecommerce and PIM product DynamicWeb. That is one ERP project shaping a PIM selection and its schedule, not an architecture every manufacturer needs. And a consumer and industrial goods group has used the PIM interface in SAP Commerce for more than fifteen years. How ERP and PLM projects move a PIM’s schedule is on how long a PIM implementation takes.
The counter-current: some manufacturers skip the dedicated PIM
Not every manufacturer here buys one. A laboratory-supplies company runs a very large catalog on an in-house database that also makes its web pages and print flyers, and rates it well. A global brewer dropped its dedicated PIM about two years before its interview and now uses its SAP ERP and commerce platforms “as both an interim PIM solution.” A B2B equipment maker expects to do product optimization “directly within Shopify” instead of buying a PIM, a plan rather than a completed change. The buyers who did buy describe the need arriving with the number of retailers and channels: one whose company considered building its own says that when it comes to connecting to Amazon and the big retailers, “you can’t really build that.”
Want your own stack read the same way?
Get mine →How does Syndigo compare with other PIM systems for manufacturers?
In these interviews, manufacturers use Syndigo for the same job as Salsify: reaching retailers. Some consumer-goods makers run both for different retailers, as the food-and-beverage maker above does, saying Syndigo is “great for managing a really large catalog” for large-format retailers such as Walmart and Target. An outdoor-power-equipment maker shopping for a PIM and DAM said it expected to “go with Syndigo because it’s used very heavily for our retail side of the business,” where its retail team already rates it well. A life-sciences equipment and supplies company vetting replacements for its commerce-suite PIM put Syndigo level with Salsify on reach for the size of its catalog, ahead of Inriver on scale; that selection was still under way. Who moves off Syndigo, and to what, is on Syndigo alternatives, and the head-to-head is on Salsify vs. Syndigo.
What this means if you are a manufacturer choosing a PIM
The accounts above sort manufacturers by where their content goes and how complex their products are. Our recommendation, drawn from these interviews rather than a process buyers describe following, is to choose in that order. List every retailer, marketplace, distributor, dealer and internal channel you send product data to, and tell apart the system that holds the master data from the services that syndicate it. For each destination that matters, confirm the vendor supports its format and submission workflow today, and test a real product feed rather than trusting a connector list.
If distributors or dealers are on the list, test what they actually need: an API, export templates, permissions or a self-service portal. If you print catalogs or spec sheets, ask each candidate to build one of your catalog pages from your own data, since in these accounts that is where tools part ways. If your products have deep variants, configurations or regional attributes, load your most complex product family during the trial and check how updates and inherited values behave.
Then settle which attributes start in the ERP, the PLM or with suppliers, and whether the ERP project comes first, because in these interviews an ERP change sets the PIM’s date more often than the PIM sets the ERP’s. Compare vendors at equal scope on the whole running cost: the software, syndication networks, connectors, implementation, data cleanup, catalog production and the team that keeps the data right. Ask what a second retailer network or a new channel adds.
What not to read into this
The shares in the table count companies whose own words about their PIM raise a job; a company that never mentions catalogs may still print them, so they are not a measure of need. The groups are drawn from company records, and many manufacturers sell both through retailers and through distributors, so the line between consumer-goods and industrial makers is a sorting, not a market definition. Rates Salsify means a buyer rated it in an interview, not that the company runs it alone or at all of its brands. Several accounts here are selections, evaluations or plans, labelled as such; a front-runner is not a purchase. And none of this is a ranking of PIM vendors for manufacturers: the vendor that suits a manufacturer depends on its channels, which is the point of the page.
Common questions
Which PIM system should a manufacturer use?
It depends on who sells the products. Manufacturers that sell through big retailers put retailer reach first: in Alium’s interviews about four in five consumer-goods makers who rate a PIM rate Salsify, and some use Syndigo alongside it for other retailers. A company can rate more than one, so this is not a market share. Makers of industrial and technical goods rate a wider mix: about half rate Salsify, and others use Syndigo, Inriver, Akeneo, Stibo Systems, Jasper, Pimcore or B2B-focused tools such as Catsy, chosen for distributor and dealer feeds, B2B and print catalogs, or deep variant sets.
How does Syndigo compare with other PIM systems for manufacturers?
In these interviews manufacturers use Syndigo for the same job as Salsify: getting product content to retailers. Some consumer-goods makers run both, because retailers differ in the networks and formats they accept. One global food-and-beverage maker uses Syndigo for large-format retailers such as Walmart and Target and says it is great for managing a really large catalog. Who moves off it and where they go is covered on Alium’s Syndigo alternatives page.
Is Salsify good for B2B manufacturers?
Buyers in Alium’s interviews split on it. A home-comfort equipment maker chose Salsify for both its ecommerce and its traditional trade distribution customers, and a building-products maker uses it to build custom catalogs its sales team sends to customers. A small industrial-tools maker replaced it with Catsy, calling Salsify excellent but expensive and built for consumer-goods companies. Salsify’s own site, checked in November 2026, has a page aimed at B2B manufacturers.
Does a manufacturer need a PIM that integrates with ERP and PLM?
Many PIMs exchange data with an ERP, though product data also comes from PLM, engineering systems and suppliers; what differs is how much the ERP decides. In Alium’s interviews ERP and PLM integration comes up about as often among consumer brands as among industrial manufacturers, so it is not a manufacturer-specific need. Where it matters, it usually sets the timing: buyers hold PIM decisions until an ERP project, or buy a commerce suite that bundles the PIM with an ERP connection.
Can a manufacturer use its ERP or ecommerce platform instead of a PIM?
Some do. In Alium’s interviews, manufacturers run product data in an in-house database, in the PIM features of their commerce platform, or in the ERP after dropping a dedicated PIM, and one B2B equipment maker plans to handle product optimization inside Shopify instead of buying a PIM. The ones that bought say the need arrived with the number of retailers and channels: a buyer whose company considered building one says you cannot really build the connections to Amazon and the big retailers yourself.
Related reading: what PIM buyers wish they’d known, where the ratings table lives; why brands switch PIM systems; Salsify alternatives; Syndigo alternatives; Salsify vs. Akeneo; Salsify vs. Inriver; and what product content syndication is.
Your stack, read by the buyers who've run it
Peer-powered: built from hundreds of verified buyer interviews, and fitted to the tools you already run. You get a shortlist for your stack and your next steps.
Get my stack readFree · no password · your answers are anonymized before they inform research like this.