Do B2B and consumer brands rate the same software the same way?
For most software, yes. For most products rated by both groups, the differences are small. Rating by rating, B2B companies average 7.3 and consumer brands 7.2, but those overall averages pool different mixes of products. The more direct test compares the same software in both groups, and there the typical gap is smaller still. The clearest exception is a selected group of six large CRM, marketing automation, analytics and digital-experience platforms: Salesforce, HubSpot, Marketo, Salesforce Marketing Cloud, Adobe Analytics and Adobe Experience Manager. Taken together, B2B buyers rate them about half a point higher than consumer brands do. The group spans different functions, so the pooled gap does not establish a shared use case or a shared cause. GA4 also rates higher with B2B buyers, but that gap narrows considerably when only marketing leaders are compared.
Who counts as which. A company is B2B here when its company record describes a business-facing company — software, IT, professional and business services, industrial, wholesale — and a consumer brand when the record describes a retailer or a consumer-goods maker. The groups are drawn so that no company sits in both. Counted by company rather than by rating, about half of the companies that rated software in these interviews are consumer brands and fewer than one in ten are B2B. The remaining four in ten sit in neither group: banks, insurers, healthcare, travel, restaurants, media and other consumer services, plus companies whose record carries both kinds of tag. Those shares describe who was interviewed, not the market.
| Group | Avg rating | Share of rating companies |
|---|---|---|
| B2B companies | 7.3 | Fewer than one in ten |
| Consumer brands | 7.2 | About half |
That near-tie shows the two groups barely differ in their overall averages in these interviews, and averaged company by company rather than rating by rating, they land in the same place. It does not mean every product is rated alike, or that the two groups rate with identical habits, and each average pools a different mix of products. The informative test is the product-by-product comparison below.
Where the two groups part ways
Every figure below is a gap, not a rating: the B2B average for a product minus the consumer-brand average for the same product. Positive means B2B buyers rated it higher, and puts the dot right of the centre line. The two pooled rows are group-level summaries, not any one platform’s rating. Each product plotted on its own row has at least twenty-five ratings in both groups, which is why the list is short; Marketo, Salesforce Marketing Cloud and Adobe Analytics are in the six-platform pool but fall below that line on one side, so they have no row of their own.
one of the six platforms everything else
| Product | −1−½ 0+½+1 | Gap |
|---|---|---|
| Six large CRM, marketing and digital-experience platforms, pooled | +0.5 | |
| Salesforce, HubSpot, Marketo, Salesforce Marketing Cloud, Adobe Analytics and Adobe Experience Manager, each rating measured against its own product’s average. | ||
| +0.6 | ||
| The CRM. Rated by both groups in similar numbers. | ||
| +0.5 | ||
| CRM and marketing automation. Rated more often by B2B companies than by consumer brands. | ||
| +0.4 | ||
| Content management. | ||
| +0.7 | ||
| Web analytics, every rater. The widest gap on this page. | ||
| +0.3 | ||
| The same product with the rater’s job held fixed. About half the gap goes. | ||
| +0.2 | ||
| Business intelligence. Close to level. | ||
| Every other product both groups rate, pooled | −0.1 | |
| The rest of the products rated often enough by both groups to compare, from data warehouses and testing tools to ad platforms and AI assistants, measured the same way as the six platforms. GA4 is left out of this row. | ||
| −0.5 | ||
| Business intelligence. The clearest product rated higher by consumer brands. | ||
Read the two pooled rows against each other. The six platforms sit about half a point right of centre; the rest of the products both groups rate, measured the same way, sit almost on it. Of the three without a row, Marketo and Salesforce Marketing Cloud lean B2B by about half a point, and Adobe Analytics by about a point.
Is it just that B2B companies are bigger?
Company size alone does not appear to account for the six-platform gap. The B2B companies in these interviews do run larger than the consumer brands, and the company-size split shows that size alone can move a product’s rating by more than a point. So the gap was also measured within four employee bands. In every band, B2B buyers rate the six platforms between about half a point and nearly a point higher than consumer brands of the same size; for the other products both groups rate, the corresponding differences are smaller or reversed. That makes size an incomplete explanation, not an eliminated one: it does not rule out other differences between the buyers or their implementations. The gap is also positive in 2026 interviews alone. Earlier years carry far fewer B2B ratings, so the full-period result is best read alongside the recent one, not as a constant over time.
Is it the software, or the job it is bought for?
The rater’s function explains more of the GA4 pattern than of the six-platform pattern. Across all GA4 raters, B2B buyers rate it about seven tenths of a point higher than consumer brands do; among marketing leaders alone, that narrows to about a third of a point. The six-platform gap, compared the same way, stays at about half a point. These are observational comparisons, not a formal estimate of how much the mix of jobs causes either difference.
GA4 is rated by different people at consumer brands. Ecommerce and digital-commerce leaders give about 36% of consumer brands’ GA4 ratings, against 12% at B2B companies, where most come from marketing leaders. Within consumer brands, those ecommerce leaders rate GA4 about half a point below marketing leaders, while across every other product the two functions rate within about a tenth of each other. That is why limiting the comparison to marketing leaders narrows the B2B lead so much, and it makes the mix of respondents a plausible contributor; differences in use case, implementation and company may remain. What the ecommerce leaders describe is a tool they keep as a reference rather than a source of truth:
A director of ecommerce at a beauty brand, asked what the brand uses for site analytics, names Google Analytics first and then explains why sales figures come from Shopify instead. “Mostly, we use GA just to have a benchmark,” they say; for the sales number, “which to me is the most important, we look directly into the source.”
An ecommerce operations director at an apparel retailer calls it “a good base mark, but you have to review it with a skeptical eye.” B2B marketing leaders describe a narrower job and seem satisfied with it: one head of marketing at a business-services company runs it “predominantly linked to our media spend and our digital advertising spend,” and a B2B software marketing leader calls it “a really effective tool for us as we look at our website analytics in particular.”
The six-platform gap does not close the same way. Restricted to marketing leaders, the pooled B2B advantage stays at about half a point, while on other products the two groups’ marketing respondents show little difference. So the six-platform finding is not primarily a role-mix effect, though the data does not establish what produces it. Filing makes no difference either: counting only ratings of Salesforce as a CRM, the gap is about the same. What buyers describe is a difference in the work done inside these platforms. B2B buyers talk about leads, opportunities and pipeline. A product marketer at a software company says what they need from Salesforce is “really just the leads that are in there, the opportunities.” A customer-marketing leader at a large industrial company says it is “huge for marketing,” because it lets them “create good visibility for sellers and business leaders to understand pipeline opportunities.”
That is a buyer’s account of their own setup, not evidence that the platform cannot serve a consumer brand; plenty of consumer brands rate it well. Our reading, not something the data proves, is that differences in the work buyers expect may contribute. For CRM and marketing automation, B2B interviews dwell on leads, opportunities, accounts and pipeline; consumer-brand interviews dwell on shopper records, store clienteling, purchase-triggered journeys, email and segmentation, which can make an implementation harder to fit. That fits the buyer accounts, especially on Salesforce. But the group also includes analytics and content management, which do different jobs, and the interviews establish neither one shared cause nor that a consumer brand gets less value from these platforms.
The counter-current: it is not the vendor, and it does not run one way
The two vendors’ lines do not all move together. Adobe Target, the testing tool, goes the other way: consumer brands rate it higher, by around a point on a thin B2B sample, and its job is the consumer storefront rather than a sales funnel. Power BI leans the same way, by about half a point, and holds when only marketing leaders are compared; the interviews do not explain it. And Tableau, which Salesforce owns and which is bought for the same job as Power BI, is close to level. These counterexamples suggest the use case may say more than the vendor name; they do not establish which requirements cause the differences.
Want this checked against your own stack?
Start my checkup →What this means for your shortlist
An aggregate rating combines buyers of different company types, responsibilities and use cases. For most products rated often by both groups, the B2B and consumer-brand averages are similar, so the split changes little. For certain CRM, marketing and digital-experience platforms the differences are larger, so who sits behind the number matters more, and their raters lean heavily one way or the other. Among ratings from companies classified as B2B or consumer brand, B2B companies contribute more than half of HubSpot’s and nearly half of Salesforce’s, against just over one in ten of all such ratings; consumer brands contribute about nine in ten of Salesforce Marketing Cloud’s and Adobe Analytics’. These shares count interview ratings, not customer bases or market shares, and they count ratings where the shares earlier on this page count companies.
Our recommendation, based on these findings rather than a standardized review process reported by the buyers, is to ask three questions before a rating narrows a shortlist. First, who contributed the ratings: which company types, how many relevant assessments, and whether your kind of business is well represented. A high overall rating may mostly reflect buyers unlike you. Second, what work they were evaluating: B2B lead and opportunity management is a different job from shopper records, segmentation and ecommerce journeys, so compare the workflows that matter to you. Third, who in those companies rated it: on GA4, marketing and ecommerce leaders differ, so check whether the raters operate the product, consume its reports or own the vendor relationship. None of this makes ratings meaningless. They show which requirements are well represented, and which need validating through demos, references or tests on your own workflows and data.
What not to read into this
These are averages from two different sets of buyers, not a before-and-after and not a measure of what a product would do for you. A higher B2B rating does not mean one of these platforms works better for B2B companies in some absolute sense, or that a consumer brand will be disappointed with it; it means that, in these interviews, the consumer brands that use it rate it lower on average. The interviews do not establish why, and the work-inside-the-system explanation is what buyers describe, not a measured cause. Individual product differences are estimates from these samples, not fixed product traits; some rest on far fewer ratings on one side and can move as interviews are added. The pooled six-platform result is more useful for the pattern, but it is not a prediction for any one platform or buyer. Most B2B ratings here come from 2026 interviews, while consumer-brand ratings span more years. The gap is positive within 2026 alone; earlier years carry fewer B2B ratings and a smaller gap, so this is a pattern in these interviews rather than a constant over time. And four in ten rating companies sit in neither group, so nothing here describes banks, insurers, healthcare or travel companies.
Common questions
Do B2B companies and consumer brands rate software differently?
Mostly not. Across all their ratings, the two groups average within about a tenth of a point of each other, and on the typical product both rate they agree closely. The clearest exception is a selected group of six large CRM, marketing, analytics and digital-experience platforms — Salesforce, HubSpot, Marketo, Salesforce Marketing Cloud and Adobe’s analytics and content platforms — which B2B buyers rate about half a point higher than consumer brands do, taken together. The group spans different jobs, so that gap does not point to one shared cause. Power BI is the clearest product that leans the other way.
Why do B2B buyers rate Salesforce and HubSpot higher than consumer brands do?
The interviews point to differences in the work done inside the system. B2B buyers describe using their CRM for leads, opportunities, accounts and pipeline. Some consumer-brand buyers describe running the same platform for shopper segmentation, store clienteling or email, and one says they do not use it the way a true B2B company would. That is what buyers say, not a measured cause. The gap stays when you compare only marketing leaders, or only ratings of the CRM, so it is not primarily a difference in who rates it or in which category it is filed under.
Why do consumer brands rate GA4 lower than B2B companies do?
Partly because of who is rating it. At consumer brands about a third of GA4 ratings come from ecommerce and digital-commerce leaders, against about one in eight at B2B companies, and those leaders rate GA4 about half a point below the marketing leaders at the same kind of company. On other products the two functions rate within about a tenth of each other. Compare marketing leaders alone and the B2B lead on GA4 narrows from about seven tenths of a point to about a third. That makes the mix of raters a plausible contributor, not a measured share of the cause. Ecommerce leaders describe using GA4 as a benchmark and checking sales in their commerce platform instead.
Is the difference between B2B and consumer ratings just company size?
Not on its own. B2B companies in these interviews run larger than consumer brands, so the gap was also measured within four company-size bands. In every band, B2B buyers rate the six large CRM, marketing and digital-experience platforms between about half a point and nearly a point higher, while for the other products both groups rate, the corresponding differences are smaller or reversed. That makes size an incomplete explanation, though it does not rule out other differences between the buyers or their implementations.
Should a consumer brand trust a Salesforce or HubSpot rating?
Treat it as a blend. For Salesforce and HubSpot a large share of the raters are B2B companies, and they rate these platforms higher than consumer brands do, so a single figure can read higher than a consumer brand’s experience. Our recommendation, not a practice buyers describe, is to ask which companies sit behind a rating, what work they were evaluating and who in those companies rated it, before letting it narrow a shortlist. For most other software the split makes little difference.
The same kind of split by company size is in does company size change how buyers rate software, and which tools each size of company runs is in how company size shapes the stack. For where analytics buyers go when GA4 stops fitting, see GA4 alternatives buyers actually switch to; for why companies keep their CRM, the CRM nobody leaves.
Get a checkup on your tech stack
A checkup for your marketing stack, built from hundreds of verified buyer interviews: what matters most to you, a shortlist for your stack, and your next steps.
Start my checkupFree · no password · your answers are anonymized before they inform research like this.