Top complaints about selling on marketplaces

Amazon draws the most seller complaints in these interviews, mostly about fees, resellers and knockoffs, largely because more of these brands sell there. Walmart's sellers describe getting connected and getting help; TikTok Shop's describe its shipping rules. Six complaints, which marketplace draws which, and what sellers say about the tools in between.

Based on verified interviews with the ecommerce, marketplace and digital leaders who run their brands' marketplace channels, at DTC and enterprise brands. Buyers are anonymized before publication; vendor names and views are reported as given. No vendor paid to appear or could edit this page.

Which platforms have the most seller complaints? In Alium Research's verified interviews with brands and retailers that sell on marketplaces, Amazon is named most often, by a wide margin, largely because more of these companies sell there than anywhere else. That measures how often complaints come up in these interviews, not what share of Amazon's sellers are unhappy. Amazon's sellers raise fees and margin, and resellers, knockoffs and price undercutting, most often, followed by listings they do not fully control, data Amazon keeps, and support that is hard to reach. Walmart's sellers here describe getting connected and getting help, and TikTok Shop's describe shipping and delivery rules set by TikTok. Six complaints recur across them all. Few sellers leave over any of them; they hire people, add tools and keep selling. The feed and listing tools that sit between a brand and its marketplaces draw a different set of complaints, led by cost and service, and get replaced more readily. For the ratings and what the category covers, see what is marketplace management software?

Amazon
Named in more seller complaints here than any other marketplace, largely because more of these brands sell there. Fees and resellers lead.
Shipping
TikTok Shop's leading complaint: delivery rules and shipping times set by TikTok, sometimes with little notice.
7.8/10
Feedonomics' buyer rating, the most-rated feed tool here. Its users fault its cost and praise its support.

Which marketplaces have the most seller complaints? Amazon, on five of the six complaints. About seven in ten of the companies that raise any marketplace complaint here name a problem with Amazon, and many raise more than one complaint, or about more than one marketplace. That reflects where these brands sell as much as how Amazon treats them: it shows where complaints concentrate, not a complaint rate or which marketplace is better. TikTok Shop's sellers concentrate on its rules, fees and onboarding; Walmart's on connecting, help and data. Zalando, eBay, Target and regional marketplaces in Southeast Asia draw scattered complaints, led by commission and fees.

Which marketplace draws which seller complaint A qualitative map from the interview corpus. A filled dot marks a complaint commonly raised by the companies complaining about that marketplace; a hollow dot marks one raised less often; an empty cell means its sellers did not raise it here. Getting connected and getting help is commonly raised about Amazon, Walmart and TikTok Shop, and less often about other marketplaces. Fees and margin is commonly raised about Amazon, TikTok Shop and other marketplaces, and less often about Walmart. Resellers and knockoffs is commonly raised about Amazon and Walmart, and less often about TikTok Shop and other marketplaces. Data the marketplace keeps and listings sellers do not control are commonly raised about Amazon and Walmart, less often about other marketplaces, and not about TikTok Shop. Rules that change are commonly raised about TikTok Shop and less often about Amazon, Walmart and other marketplaces. Amazon Walmart TikTok Shop Other marketplaces Getting connected and helped Fees and margin Resellers and knockoffs Data the marketplace keeps Listings you don't control Rules that change commonly raisedraised less oftenempty: not raised here
Where companies that complain about each marketplace raise each complaint — a qualitative read, not a score. A filled dot means a complaint is common among that marketplace's complaining companies, not among all its sellers; an empty cell means it did not come up here, not that the problem is absent. Amazon rests on several times as many companies as the other columns, so they are not equal samples; Walmart rests on few, often named alongside Amazon, so read its column as cases. Other marketplaces groups Zalando, eBay, Target, retailer marketplaces and regional ones in Southeast Asia.
This is what buyers in general found. What fits your stack?A free tech stack review, built from hundreds of verified buyer interviews.
Get my stack review →

The six complaints — graded

Each complaint is grouped by how sellers in these interviews respond: tolerating it, working around it, or changing how much, or how, they sell. These are observed patterns, not numerical severity ratings. A complaint one brand lives with can be the reason another keeps a marketplace small.

Complaint 01 Often worked around — with people, connectors and contractors

Getting connected, and getting help

The complaint raised by the most companies, about three in ten of those complaining about any marketplace: the work of plugging a business into a marketplace and running it, and how hard it is to get help when something breaks. On Amazon it is the operating burden and the support. A consumer-hardware brand says “Amazon is very difficult to work with. They are very, very challenging when something goes wrong to troubleshoot,” and adds “You could get a university degree in how to run the e-commerce platform on Amazon and still not get it right.” A multi-brand consumer-products company says “they take a lot of money and they're extremely hard to work with to fix anything.” On Walmart it is the connection. A consumer-electronics seller, told to load a new item another way, says “our instructions are to email someone on their internal team directly, not even through their portal,” and an apparel manufacturer will not add marketplaces “until everything can go through Shopify with the product listings, product fees, pricing, inventory.” TikTok Shop draws it at onboarding: a craft brand says “The amount of talk to get on boarded to TikTok shop was just, and the communication is terrible.” Zalando draws it from an outdoor footwear brand: “The difficulty with Zalando is mostly that there are so many different teams that don't really talk to each other.” Not every seller finds Walmart the harder one: a large apparel company says of Amazon “Getting Amazon up and running took us a long time. It's been much faster to get Walmart up.” Sellers answer with people: a dedicated Amazon specialist, an agency, a contractor alongside an integration vendor.

Named for this: Amazon · Walmart · TikTok Shop · Zalando

Complaint 02 Decides how much a brand sells there — and behind the one exit

Fees and margin

What a marketplace takes, and what it costs to be seen there. It is the complaint Amazon's sellers raise most, with resellers. A consumer-products brand says “Amazon fees continue to be challenging,” and a pet-supplements brand describes “a lot of margin pressure coming from Amazon and TikTok Shop.” An apparel manufacturer says its owners will not shut Amazon off “even though the margins are getting slimmer and slimmer every single year.” Outside the US it is commission: a fashion retailer in Southeast Asia sees more sales coming from marketplaces, “which also keeps increasing the commission fee,” and a multinational food company's business in the region says “Shopee and TikTok Shop are very expensive to operate on that, so it's one of the biggest challenges.” The cost of being seen sits on top: a global footwear brand describes TikTok Shop as “more and more competitive with the creators and the amount of marketing we need to spend.” This is the complaint that shapes the channel. An apparel brand that sells mostly direct kept Amazon small on purpose — “we always wanted it to be less than 5% because it was more margin dilutive” — and another makes products for Amazon at an opening price point “so that we can hit our target margin.” It is also behind the one completed exit here, below. For what the advertising tools themselves draw, see top complaints about retail media platforms.

Named for this: Amazon · TikTok Shop · Shopee · retailer marketplaces

Complaint 03 Fought, not fled — with enforcement services and pricing policies

Resellers, knockoffs and price undercutting

Three related problems: knockoffs that infringe a brand's trademark or patent, genuine products sold by resellers it did not authorize, and prices that undercut its own. Almost all of it is about Amazon, though Walmart comes up too, and the remedies differ: a knockoff is an IP claim, while a genuine product at the wrong price is a question of distribution and pricing policy. An outdoor footwear brand says “Amazon has opened so many of the floodgates, again, to almost anybody to sell,” describing product bought at off-price stores and resold on Amazon against the brand. A wellness brand group says “resellers are undercutting us on price and opening up stores on Amazon and Walmart,” and a bedding manufacturer that measured its price violations says “We kind of look like a scam, honestly.” Knockoffs are the other half: a multi-brand consumer-products company says “We have knockoffs on the other brand that we can't get Amazon to do anything about it.” Price matching makes it worse: a global beauty group says of the marketplaces “They are aggressively price matching other players on the market.” Sellers fight it rather than leave. A home-products manufacturer bought Red Points for “the patent infringement and knockoff product problem that we have on Amazon,” and says two of its people spend hours on it; a consumer-products brand used an enforcement vendor to remove most of the third-party sellers undercutting it; others run MAP monitoring and takedown notices. Amazon's Brand Registry, free for brands with a pending or registered trademark, offers automated protections and a Report a Violation tool. Project Zero lets brands with a registered trademark and a record of accurate reports remove counterfeit listings themselves, free, and Transparency puts a unique serial code on every unit to stop counterfeits, charged per unit, per Amazon's pages checked in November 2026. Walmart's Brand Portal takes copyright, trademark, patent and counterfeit claims from brand owners with an active US trademark registration, a separate IP Claim Form takes counterfeit reports, and Walmart says it does not mediate or enforce disputes between resellers and suppliers, authorized or unauthorized, per its marketplace guides, also checked in November 2026. These programs act on counterfeits and infringement, not on genuine product resold below a brand's price; that is what the policies and vendors above are for.

Named for this: Amazon · Walmart · Red Points

Complaint 04 Mostly tolerated — or bought from a third party

Data the marketplace keeps

Selling through a marketplace means not knowing the customer, and on Amazon's wholesale side not seeing much of the sale either. A global consumer-goods company says “the challenge is they own our customer data or own the insights,” and a global beauty company that the key challenge is “to know the customers that are sitting on the retailer's websites.” A bedding manufacturer says “you know nothing about these people and it makes it hard to develop product.” On Vendor Central, a large packaged-food manufacturer says “We'd love to see the average selling price for a particular item as well as the net profitability for the item, but Amazon does not share that,” and a media company's consumer-products business says of customer data “absolutely not. They will not share any of that.” Walmart's version is reporting: a global consumer-electronics company says “For tracking data at Walmart, this is mostly done in an Excel tool which is shared. This is a struggle, I would say.” Sellers mostly live with it, or buy what they can: a global apparel brand pays for third-party marketplace analytics for “information that is difficult to access in Vendor Central.”

Named for this: Amazon Vendor Central · Amazon · Walmart

Complaint 05 Often worked around — by watching the listings

Listings you don't control

Product pages that change, split or slip in ways the seller did not ask for. A multi-brand consumer-products company says “Amazon changes their backend monthly, weekly,” which makes listing creation “so big of a pain.” A large apparel company says “there's all kinds of challenges of who actually originally owns the ASIN. And it's messy,” and a large packaged-food manufacturer says one product's ASIN “can be attributed to four to six different vendor codes, making it extremely challenging to manage.” An automotive products company says “Amazon has now broken apart our product reviews that were previously aggregated or syndicated between the two products,” forcing it to relaunch the newer version. A sporting-goods manufacturer describes product pages that split apart, after which “you lose all your sales ranking capabilities.” A toy company sees “a significant amount of change on the attributes and catalog management from Amazon, Walmart, and Target.” Sellers watch for it rather than prevent it: the sporting-goods manufacturer crawls its own pages and files tickets automatically when one breaks, and the toy company hired a second content vendor to keep up.

Named for this: Amazon · Walmart · Target

Complaint 06 Mostly tolerated — and once, a change of selling model

Rules that change

Shipping requirements, suspensions and selling models a marketplace changes on its own schedule. It is TikTok Shop's leading complaint. A fragrance company says “They just said if you're going to sell, you have to use our delivery mechanism, our parcel service, our delivery codes, and it just has made it difficult,” and that “It was all just done without much notice and without much clarity.” A fitness-apparel brand runs TikTok Shop as a separate channel, “facing unique challenges with discounts and shipping times, which we’ve also received some trouble for,” and a footwear brand names “Increased fees and logistical shipping issues, as well as unknowns about the TikTok marketplace.” Retailer marketplaces draw it too: a footwear and accessories brand says “so many of them have requirements on shipping. They're very aggressive and it's hard on our warehouse.” On Amazon it is rarer but heavier. A consumer-electronics brand says “We had an issue with an account suspension and got some of our reviews removed. We're starting from scratch essentially.” Walmart is moving a consumer-electronics seller's wholesale online business onto its marketplace, “which will be a multi-year thing.” The largest case is a global footwear brand that Amazon pushed back to selling wholesale, below. For TikTok Shop's current shipping options, see TikTok Shop pros and cons.

Named for this: TikTok Shop · Amazon · Walmart · retailer marketplaces

Do these complaints make brands stop selling on a marketplace? Rarely. One completed exit appears here: a fashion retailer that had stopped selling on Amazon when it spoke to us, over margin, customer data and the brand. The other moves change how much, or how, a brand sells there, and are not exits: an apparel brand deliberately keeps Amazon small for margin; a global footwear brand was partway through returning to selling wholesale to Amazon after Amazon shut down some of its indirect business there; a packaged-foods company has moved part of its business from selling on Amazon to selling to Amazon, and says it now has “much less control”; and one brand delayed further investment in TikTok Shop over uncertainty about the platform. Several weigh whether a marketplace is worth it, and several worry that it takes sales from their own site. Most complaining sellers stay.

Which marketplace management tools draw the most complaints? These tools do different jobs, so their complaints differ. Feedonomics calls itself product data feed management; Rithum offers marketplace listings, product feeds and dropship; Helium 10 sells seller tools for Amazon, Walmart and TikTok Shop, from product research to analytics. Mirakl is software for running a marketplace or dropship program, and its users here sit on both sides: retailers that run their own marketplace on it, and brands that sell through it. The complaints follow the job: cost on Feedonomics, feeds and service on Rithum, terms and customization on Mirakl, and data and interface on Helium 10. Feedonomics, the most-rated, averages 7.8 out of 10; Helium 10 rates around 8, Rithum around 7.5 and Mirakl around 6.5. Because the jobs differ, the ratings are not a head-to-head. The full ratings table is on what is marketplace management software?

What users of the most-named marketplace tools complain about and praise, from verified interviews through November 2026. The tools do different jobs, from feeds to running a marketplace, so this is a qualitative summary, not a ranking.
Tool What its users complain about What its users praise
Feedonomics Cost, raised more than anything else, including fees that keep rising; an interface that leans on its support team; occasional broken feeds; slow service outside the US Support and service, often from the same users who fault the price; feeds built separately for each channel
Rithum Feeds that fall out of step with the store or a marketplace's changes; a managed service slow to respond; limited flexibility Breadth of marketplace connections; a stable platform that is easy for retailers and their suppliers to use
Mirakl New features sold as paid add-ons; customization that is hard to get; support that improves on a paid plan; flat-file inventory uploads in one brand's setup Stability, ease of use, and being built for running a drop-ship or seller marketplace
Helium 10 Data and keyword results users do not fully trust; an interface and access controls they find clumsy; caps on some features Value for money, especially for a brand starting out on Amazon; market and competitor research

On Feedonomics, an online jewelry retailer says “it's pricey. It's not a cheap service,” and a B2B supplies distributor that “The price just kept going up and up and really eating into our margins.” On Rithum, a global footwear brand on its managed service says “we just have a very long time period before we receive responses,” and a national retailer selling on marketplaces says “Rithum sometimes does not always adapt the feature” when marketplaces change; Rithum is the name CommerceHub and ChannelAdvisor took at the end of 2023, after combining in 2022, per Rithum's own site, and buyers still call it either. On Mirakl, a European grocery group says “more and more, the new features are paid add-ons rather than evolutions of the base package,” and a home-decor brand selling through it says “Their support is lacking unless you have a paid plan.” A luxury childrenswear brand describes uploading inventory “with a flat file, which is not great” in its 2025 setup; Mirakl's developer documentation, checked in November 2026, also offers sellers an offer-import API. On Helium 10, a pet-health brand says “It's not always the most accurate data, and the UI can be a bit clunky at times.”

Companies here change tools more often than they leave marketplaces, and each completed tool move covers one job, not a whole marketplace operation: a small online retailer cancelled Rithum's managed feed service, a brand-licensing company took its feeds in-house from Feedonomics because “it got outrageously expensive,” a footwear brand moved its product feeds from Channable to DataFeedWatch as cheaper and more stable, and an apparel company replaced ChannelAdvisor's full-service eBay management with its own hire on a self-service tool. A consumer-electronics seller dropped CedCommerce for eBay after a price increase but kept it for Walmart, a partial withdrawal rather than a departure. Others are weighing cheaper feed tools without having moved, and a national specialty retailer stays on Rithum because of the switching costs.

Want a review of your own stack?

Get my review →

The stories behind the complaints

Pushed back to wholesale: a footwear brand and Amazon. A global footwear brand had walked away from selling wholesale to Amazon and sold through resellers instead, until “Amazon started shutting down some of our indirect business on there and basically forcing a conversation with us to come back direct on the platform.” Its reason for leaving still stands: “the model doesn't work well for fashion, footwear, or anything where there's trend.” What it won in return was protection: “We will be able to be brand-gated, which will help a lot with some of the pricing and counterfeit challenges we've had in the past on there.” The return was under way when it spoke, and on the same list of challenges sat TikTok Shop, now “a really big part of our business” and getting more expensive to compete on. Marketplaces leader · global footwear brand
The one exit: margin, data and the brand. A fashion retailer that once built an Amazon business had stopped selling there when it spoke to us. “We're giving Amazon all their margins, we don't get any customer data. It just wasn't worth the squeeze,” its ecommerce operations director says, and “we just felt it was potentially diluting the brand in the long term.” The door is not closed: “It's definitely always on the table, for sure.” Ecommerce operations director · fashion retailer
A managed feed service, cancelled. A small online retailer hired a feed vendor's managed service to run its product feed and found it out of date after a site migration. “It was a week before anyone else followed up with any kind of information,” its CMO says, and the feeds it was sent back had “incorrect quantity information, the wrong products listed that weren't on our website.” It cancelled the contract: “The software itself might work, but the service that we got from the people there, which in a managed service is quite important, was pretty terrible.” Chief marketing officer · small online retailer

The counter-current: why sellers stay

Why do brands keep selling on marketplaces they complain about? Because the same marketplace is often their biggest channel. The consumer-hardware brand that calls Amazon very difficult to work with also calls it “an incredibly powerful system when you get it right.” The fashion retailer that left remembers its first listings going “gangbusters overnight.” The outdoor footwear brand frustrated by Zalando's teams values its “reach and scale” and a look that is “quite a bit more premium than Amazon is.” The tools split the same way: the home-decor brand that finds Mirakl's support thin without a paid plan says “the cost of the platform was free, so it didn't cost us anything to get started,” the luxury childrenswear brand that dislikes its flat files calls Mirakl “Super easy to use,” and a beauty retailer that found Mirakl hard to work with years ago says the company has “done better with some of the people they've hired around the US market.” Feedonomics' cost critics are often its support's fans. Before deciding a marketplace or a tool is the problem, separate what it controls from what depends on your catalog, your pricing policy and your team.

What this means — whether you run one or you're buying one

If you already sell on marketplaces, most sellers here change how they operate rather than leave: they staff the channel, add integrations, police their listings and resellers, and buy the data the marketplace will not share. Margin is the clear limit, because it decides how much of the business a brand will put there. If you are adding a marketplace or choosing a tool, three recommendations, ours rather than practices buyers describe: work out what the channel contributes after commission, fulfilment, returns, advertising, software and the people to run it, and which products earn a place there; settle trademark protection, authorized distribution and a lawful approach to advertised pricing before you list, since the marketplaces' programs act on infringement and counterfeits rather than on price, and have counsel review any MAP or reseller restrictions; and test a feed or listing tool with your real products and orders, priced at the volume you expect, and ask who fixes a feed when it breaks. What this page cannot tell you is which marketplace is worse to sell on: the counts follow where these brands sell, and no figure here is a complaint rate. For the category and its ratings, see what is marketplace management software?; for TikTok Shop in depth, TikTok Shop pros and cons; and for the advertising tools, top complaints about retail media platforms.

Common questions

Which platforms have the most seller complaints?

In Alium's verified interviews with brands and retailers, Amazon is named in the most seller complaints, largely because more of them sell there than anywhere else; that is how often complaints come up here, not a complaint rate. Its sellers raise fees and margin, and resellers, knockoffs and price undercutting, most often. Walmart's sellers here describe getting connected and getting help, and TikTok Shop's describe shipping and fulfilment rules. Walmart and TikTok Shop rest on far fewer companies than Amazon.

What are the most common complaints about selling on Amazon?

Fees and margin, and resellers, knockoffs and price undercutting, each raised by about three in ten of the companies that complain about selling on Amazon in these interviews. After those come listings and catalog data sellers do not fully control, customer and sales data Amazon does not share, and support that is hard to reach when something breaks. Most of these sellers stay and work around the problems, with brand-protection services, analytics tools and dedicated staff.

What do sellers complain about on Walmart and TikTok Shop?

On Walmart, sellers in these interviews describe integrations that are hard to set up, internal teams that are hard to reach, and sales data they track by hand; several of its complaints name it alongside Amazon. On TikTok Shop, they describe shipping and delivery rules set by TikTok with little notice, fees and the creator spend it takes to sell, and a slow onboarding. Both rest on far fewer companies than Amazon, so read them as cases rather than shares.

What are the complaints about marketplace management software?

In these interviews, Feedonomics' users raise its cost most, and often praise its support in the same breath; Rithum's (formerly ChannelAdvisor) describe feeds that drift out of step with the store and a slow managed service; Mirakl's, both retailers running a marketplace on it and brands selling through it, describe paid add-ons, limited customization and support that improves on a paid plan; and Helium 10's describe data and an interface they do not fully trust. Feedonomics rates 7.8 out of 10, Helium 10 around 8, Rithum around 7.5 and Mirakl around 6.5; the tools do different jobs, so the ratings are not a head-to-head.

Do these complaints make brands stop selling on a marketplace?

Rarely. In these interviews one fashion retailer had stopped selling on Amazon, over margin, customer data and the brand. Other moves change how a brand sells rather than end it: an apparel brand keeps Amazon small because it dilutes margin, a global footwear brand was returning to selling wholesale to Amazon after Amazon shut down some of its indirect business there, and a packaged-foods company moved part of its business to selling to Amazon. Most complaining sellers stay and work around the problems. Companies here change feed and listing tools more often than they leave marketplaces, usually over cost or service.

A tech stack review, powered by the buyers who've been there

What matters most to you, a shortlist for your stack, and the next steps to take — built from hundreds of verified buyer interviews.

Get my stack review

Free · no password · your answers are anonymized before they inform research like this.

Want to come back to this?We'll email you a link to this page, so it's easy to find later or forward to your team.
Methodology. Alium conducts verified interviews with software buyers — the ecommerce, marketplace and digital leaders who choose and run their companies' sales channels and tools. This page aggregates what brands and retailers that sell on marketplaces say about selling there, and what users of marketplace feed and listing tools say about those tools, in interviews conducted through November 2026. Only complaints a company makes about its own selling or its own tool are counted; prospects' objections, consultants, previous employers and advertising-tool complaints are excluded, and retailers running their own marketplace are left out of the marketplace complaints, though they appear among Mirakl's users. Complaints are counted once per company per theme and coded by theme, and one company can appear under several complaints and several marketplaces. On the chart, a complaint is marked commonly raised when at least one in five of the companies complaining about that marketplace, and at least two companies, mention it; the share is of complaining companies, not of all a marketplace's sellers. The codings are editorial readings of interview content, not survey scores, and the counts are not rates. Amazon's Seller Central and Vendor Central are counted together as Amazon. Ratings are averages of verified buyer ratings; the full table is on the marketplace management definition page. Vendor facts were checked against the vendors' own pages in November 2026. Buyer identities are verified at interview time and anonymized before publication; vendor names are reported as given. No vendor paid to appear or was able to edit this page.