At what software rating does shopping activity increase?
Shopping becomes more common below 8, but even a very low score usually comes without active evaluation. In Alium’s interviews, about 4% to 5% of owners who rate a tool 8 to 10 are in market for its category or naming another vendor’s product; at 1 to 4 it is 15% to 19%. The category matters too. Low-rated ecommerce and email platforms show substantially more shopping activity than low-rated CRM, analytics and BI tools, while well-rated tools in all of them show about the same low share. These are evaluations and named alternatives at the time of the interview, not completed switches or confirmed plans to retire the tool.
What counts as shopping
Every figure on this page is a share of rated tools: each time a buyer rated a tool they use from 1 to 10, and whether they showed a shopping signal for its category at the time of the interview. One buyer can rate several tools. It is not a share of companies, not a churn rate and not a market share. Three stages are easy to run together, so the page keeps them apart.
Rating
The buyer’s score, from 1 to 10, for a tool they run today. A tool they had already left is not counted.
Shopping
At the time of the interview, the buyer is in market for that tool’s category, or names a product from another vendor in it that they are evaluating or considering. Either can mean a replacement, an addition or an expansion; neither shows a plan to retire the tool.
Replacing
A replacement has been chosen, or a migration is under way. This page does not measure it, and a buyer can shop and then stay.
The two signals in that definition are measured and reported separately. One reads whether the buyer was in market for the category when interviewed. The other reads whether they named a specific product from another vendor. They follow similar patterns but do not pick out exactly the same buyers, so a category gets a figure on this page only where the two roughly agree.
Where does the rise start?
Across all categories together, both signals stay low and nearly flat from 10 down to 8, rise at 7, rise more sharply at 6 and 5, and peak at 1 to 4. Being in market goes from 5% at 8 to 12% at 6 and 19% at 1 to 4; naming an alternative goes from 4% to 9% to 15%.
| Rating given | In market for the category | Named an alternative |
|---|---|---|
| 9 or 10 | 5% | 4% |
| 8 | 5% | 4% |
| 7 | 7% | 6% |
| 6 | 12% | 9% |
| 5 | 17% | 12% |
| 1 to 4 | 19% | 15% |
Two things follow. The first increase, at 7, is small: 7% and 6%, against 5% and 4% at 8. The sharper rise comes at 6, at 12% and 9%, and at 5, at 17% and 12%. These are differences between groups of owners, not a threshold at which any one buyer becomes likely to replace a tool. And even at the bottom of the scale most owners show neither signal, so a low score is a reason to look at category, contract timing and stated plans, not evidence of an imminent switch.
Which categories do unhappy owners shop in most?
Ecommerce and email platforms. Among owners who rate one 5 or below, 26% to 28% of ecommerce-platform owners and 22% to 24% of email-platform owners show a shopping signal, against about 13% in analytics and BI and 9% to 11% in CRM. Grouped, that is roughly two to one, though CRM sits a little below analytics and BI. Above 7, the two groups are hard to tell apart.
Share of rated tools whose owner showed a shopping signal for that tool’s category when interviewed. Each line is the midpoint of the two signals, drawn for visual comparison, and the shaded band spans them; the midpoint is not the share of buyers showing either or both. One group pools ecommerce and email platforms, the other CRM, analytics and BI, with analytics tools contributing most of the second group’s ratings; CRM alone sits a little lower.
Experimentation, reviews and content-management tools sit between those two groups on both signals. The order belongs to unhappy owners only: among tools rated 8 or above, every category here shows a shopping signal 6% of the time or less.
| Category | Rated 5 or below | Rated 8 or above |
|---|---|---|
| Ecommerce platforms | 26–28% | 2–3% |
| Email platforms | 22–24% | 3–5% |
| Experimentation | 17–22% | 3% |
| Reviews | 15–20% | 4–5% |
| Content and asset management | 14–16% | 4–6% |
| Analytics and BI | 13% | 4–5% |
| CRM | 9–11% | 4–5% |
Five categories are left out because the two signals disagree. For customer data platforms, loyalty, order management and ERP, customer service and personalization tools, the in-market share and the named-alternative share land more than ten points apart among tools rated 5 or below. In each, owners more often report being in market for the category than name a specific product from another vendor. That disagreement makes them harder to compare with the rest, so they get no figure here. Some of those shoppers may be looking for a tool to add rather than one to replace, but the interviews do not establish a single explanation.
Is it company size, or one big platform?
Neither appears to account for it fully, on the checks we could run. Larger companies’ unhappy owners show a little less shopping overall, but ecommerce and email platforms sit above CRM, analytics and BI in every company-size band, from under 200 employees to over 10,000. Removing the most common platform from each category leaves the order in place, and counting each company once per category instead of each interview gives the same picture. These checks make the pattern sturdier; they do not explain it. Contract terms, which products were chosen, how mature an implementation is, what depends on it and what buyers mean by shopping may all play a part.
Why do unhappy CRM and analytics owners shop less?
The interviews do not test the cause, but the low-rated owners in each group describe their tools differently. What follows is what buyers say. The connection we draw between it and the gap is ours.
Commerce and email shoppers describe a moment. The owners who are shopping tend to name the thing that opened the question. For one email-platform owner it is the calendar: “We also have our annual contract renewal date in August, so this is the perfect time to explore potential alternatives.” For another, at a financial-services firm, it is the vendor: “The package that we’ve got is being deprecated by the company.” A commerce leader who rates their platform 3 makes the same point about an unsupported version, and does not pretend the move is easy: “changing our entire tech stack, our e-commerce tech stack is a major undertaking,” but “since the version we have is unsupported, chances are we will actually move on from it.”
CRM owners describe a system other things depend on. Asked whether they are considering alternatives to the CRM they rate 5, one buyer answers that it is “one of those key tenants that it’s extremely hard to rip and replace.” Another explains that “so much of everything is tied through it and flows through it, that’ll be hard to replace.” A third, rating theirs 4, calls it “the source of truth for every company that I’ve worked at.” When these owners act on a low rating, what they describe is often work inside the tool rather than shopping: one company is “downsizing the footprint” of its licenses first and leaving any replacement until afterwards.
Analytics owners often did not choose the tool on its merits. A buyer rating their web analytics 3 says “if it wasn’t a free tool, I don’t think anyone would use it.” Another, on a BI tool that came with the company’s software licenses: “it’s not like because it’s a good choice, it’s because it’s a free choice.” A tool that costs nothing has no renewal to argue about.
One possible explanation, ours and not a finding, is that dissatisfaction turns into evaluation more readily where there is a defined decision point and a team able to act on it. The email and commerce owners quoted here point to a renewal, a deprecated package and an unsupported version; the CRM owners point to what depends on the system; and some analytics tools are free or came bundled. That may help explain the pattern, but the interviews do not measure the causes. Commerce migrations can be just as hard, as the counter-current below shows, and not every email contract creates an opening. It is a reason to look at decision timing and dependencies, not a universal explanation.
The counter-current: switching cost is not only a CRM problem
Commerce owners describe migrations every bit as heavy, and at least one is not shopping for exactly that reason. One owner who rates their ecommerce platform 5 says “I am not thinking about replacing because it would be a big migration,” and that the team does not have the people to run one alongside day-to-day operations. So a hard migration alone does not explain the gap. What the CRM and analytics answers add is that other teams and systems lean on the tool, or that nobody pays for it.
Want a review of your own stack?
Get my review →What to do with this
Everything in this section is our recommendation, not a practice buyers describe.
- Read a low rating within its category, not as a universal replacement threshold. Among owners who rate a tool 5 or below, ecommerce and email platforms show higher shopping-signal shares than CRM, analytics and BI, but in every category here most low-rated tools come with no active evaluation. Use the rating to find where dissatisfaction is worth investigating, and look separately for an actual buying process.
- If you own a low-rated commerce or email platform, find the real decision window. That means renewal dates, notice periods, deprecated features, support timelines and the people a migration would need. If replacement is on the table, start comparing alternatives and testing a migration early. Shoppers here describe a renewal or an end of support opening the question, but that does not apply to every product or company.
- If you own a low-rated CRM, analytics or BI tool, look at the obstacles and the alternatives separately. List the teams that depend on it, the data and integrations it holds, its costs and contract terms, and the specific problems its users have. Then weigh fixing the setup, trimming unused licenses, adding a complementary tool, or replacing it with a migration plan that covers each dependency. Less shopping in these categories does not mean a tool should stay if it fails your requirements.
- Do not read the absence of shopping as satisfaction or a safe renewal. Most owners who rate a tool 1 to 4 show neither signal, and many of them have serious problems with it. If you are one of them, find out what is blocking action, whether budget, timing, migration cost, the lack of a better option, other priorities or a decision to improve the setup, rather than assuming which.
What this does not show
It is not a switching rate. Shopping is a stage before any decision, and a buyer who shops can stay. How often low-rated tools are still there later is a different question, which why buyers keep software they rate poorly looks at.
A rating does not cause shopping. The figures compare different buyers at different ratings, not one buyer whose score fell, so they show that low ratings and shopping go together, not that a lower score pushes a buyer to shop. A buyer already shopping may also rate their current tool more harshly.
The signals miss some shoppers and catch some who are adding rather than replacing. A buyer who wants out but names no alternative and is not in market is not counted, and neither is one who has already chosen a replacement. Both kinds turn up in each group of categories at similar rates. Either signal can also mark a tool meant to sit beside the one rated, which is particularly common in analytics. So the shares are not direct replacement-shopping rates, and this page does not establish how far confirmed replacement intent differs between categories.
These are interviewed buyers, not the market. The shares describe the buyers Alium has interviewed, not every company that runs these tools, so read the gaps between categories rather than any single figure as a market rate.
Common questions
At what rating do software buyers start shopping for alternatives?
In Alium’s buyer interviews there is no single line. Among owners who rate a tool 8, 9 or 10 out of 10, about 4% to 5% are in market for its category or naming another vendor’s product, each signal measured separately. The shares rise slightly at 7, more sharply at 6 and 5, and reach 15% to 19% at 1 to 4. Even among the unhappiest owners most show neither signal, and these are signs of evaluation, not plans to replace the tool.
Which software categories do unhappy buyers shop most often?
Ecommerce platforms and email platforms. Among owners who rate one 5 or below, about a quarter show a shopping signal when interviewed. Experimentation, reviews and content-management tools sit lower, and CRM, analytics and BI sit lowest, at about one in ten to one in eight. Among tools rated 8 or above, every one of these categories shows a similar, low share. A shopping signal can mean an addition as well as a replacement.
Does a low software rating mean a buyer is about to switch?
No. These figures measure shopping signals, meaning the buyer is in market for the category or is evaluating a named product from another vendor, not switching. Either can mean adding a tool rather than replacing one, and a buyer can shop and then stay. Even at the lowest ratings most owners show neither signal, and in CRM more than eight in ten owners who rate their system 5 or below show neither.
Why do unhappy CRM owners show less shopping activity than unhappy ecommerce owners?
The interviews do not test the cause. What CRM buyers describe is a system other teams and tools depend on: one calls it the source of truth, another says so much of everything is tied through it that it will be hard to replace. Analytics buyers often describe a tool that was free or came bundled. Our reading, not a finding, is that these tools less often present a point at which one team can decide to look, while an email or commerce platform often has a renewal date or an end of support that does.
Related reading: why buyers keep software they rate poorly; replacing a system or buying the first one; the CRM nobody loves and nobody leaves; and, for the commerce side, why brands replatform.
A tech stack review, powered by the buyers who've been there
What matters most to you, a shortlist for your stack, and the next steps to take — built from hundreds of verified buyer interviews.
Get my stack reviewFree · no password · your answers are anonymized before they inform research like this.