Where do companies go when they switch software?
It depends on the category. In Alium’s interviews, about 66% of completed commerce-platform moves ended on Shopify, against a matched benchmark of 61%, and about 43% of helpdesk moves ended on Gorgias, against 37%. Shopify is the majority destination; Gorgias is the most common single helpdesk destination without holding a majority. Both shares are broadly consistent with existing adoption among comparable companies, though a sample this size cannot show that they match their benchmarks exactly. In email platforms, BI, CMS, reviews, site search and A/B testing, no destination takes more than about a quarter of the moves, and the destinations furthest above their benchmark there are tools still uncommon among similar companies, led by Braze in email and Sigma in BI.
A move here means a company that stopped using one tool and now runs a named tool for the same job, as the buyer described it in the interview. It is what the interview recorded, not an audit of contracts, and departures that ended in an in-house build or no replacement are not counted. The comparison point, which the chart calls similar companies, is a matched installed-base benchmark: for each completed move, the destination is set against the tools already recorded at other interviewed companies of similar size and, outside commerce platforms, the same Shopify use, with the tool being replaced excluded and the remaining tools reweighted, then combined across the category’s moves. It shows where moves would fall if switchers picked replacements in proportion to their presence in comparable companies’ stacks. It is not an observed migration rate, a market share or a prediction of any buyer’s choice, and it adjusts for size and Shopify use, not for industry, budget, technical needs or product availability.
Each thick bar splits one category’s completed, buyer-reported moves by destination. Each thin bar shows the matched installed-base benchmark: the hypothetical destination split from the tools used at other interviewed companies of similar size and Shopify use (size alone for commerce platforms), excluding the tool each switcher left. It compares observed destinations with adoption at comparable companies and is not a forecast. The leading destination is shaded dark in both. The palest segment groups every destination past the eighth. Categories rest on a few dozen moves each and more in email, so read the shapes and gaps rather than the decimals.
Where switchers converge, they land on the default
Where switchers converge, established adoption helps explain the leaders. Commerce platforms show the strongest concentration. Shopify takes two in three moves, and it is also the most common platform among comparable companies, at about 61% of commerce platforms, so switchers are landing on it at close to the rate their peers already run it. One buyer who moved from an older platform put the reasoning plainly: “Shopify is the leader in the space for a reason.” The fifth of switchers who went to Salesforce Commerce Cloud were typically much larger companies than those who went to Shopify, and that share sits almost exactly on its size-matched benchmark.
Helpdesks show a related but less concentrated pattern. Gorgias takes more than four in ten helpdesk moves, against about a quarter of helpdesks across all the companies in these interviews. But the companies changing helpdesks are a particular group: nearly nine in ten run Shopify, against about half of the other companies running these helpdesks, and they are mostly small. Among companies like them, Gorgias is already the most common helpdesk, at about 37%, and most of the gap closes. One buyer described Gorgias against their previous helpdesk as “just better built for e-commerce”.
In both converging categories, the most common tool among similar companies is the one switchers land on most, at a share close to its benchmark. That is consistent with adoption helping explain destinations, not with every such buyer following one default. So the concentration says less about unusual momentum than raw shares suggest: the switchers share characteristics with organizations already using the leaders, which helps explain why Shopify and Gorgias appear so prominently, without showing that peer adoption caused any choice.
| Category | Leading destination | Share of moves | Expected | Shape |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commerce platforms | Shopify | 66% | 61% | Majority to the most common platform |
| Helpdesks | Gorgias | 43% | 37% | Leads; already most common among small Shopify stores |
| Email platforms | Braze | 22% | 7% | Three-way split by company size; Braze well above its benchmark |
| Reviews | Bazaarvoice | 24% | 26% | Spread out, in line with its benchmark |
| BI and dashboards | Power BI | 24% | 34% | More spread out than its benchmark |
| CMS | AEM and Contentful | 21% each | 18 / 27% | More spread out than its benchmark |
| Site search | Constructor | 20% | 4% | More spread out than its benchmark |
| A/B testing | AB Tasty, Adobe Target and VWO | 13% each | 7 / 18 / 12% | More spread out than its benchmark |
Where the market is fragmented, switchers scatter
Where the matched installed base is fragmented, moves usually spread across several destinations. In BI, CMS, site search and A/B testing no product takes more than about a quarter, and in all four the observed split is more dispersed than its benchmark. That does not mean every product gets fewer moves than expected: Constructor takes about 20% of site-search moves against a 4% benchmark while the rest spread out. Reviews show another kind of spread. Bazaarvoice takes about 24% of reviews moves against a 26% benchmark, consistent with a category whose adoption is itself spread. That holds even though most of the reviews switchers run Shopify, so a shared commerce platform alone does not produce a default.
In these categories buyers describe choosing rather than defaulting. One buyer who folded two BI tools into one says “we evaluated a bunch of different tools, and we landed on Sigma Computing.” Another, replacing an older testing tool, says “we did our RFP process for that and then ended up with Statsig.”
Testing shows especially dispersed destinations here. AB Tasty, Adobe Target and VWO take about 13% each, and no replacement dominates. About a third of the testing moves followed departures from Google Optimize, which Google discontinued in September 2023, and those companies picked six different tools. That shows how users of a discontinued product can spread across several alternatives; it describes these moves, not a rule for every shutdown.
Email: three destinations, sorted by size
Email moves spread across several destinations, with a visible size pattern. Braze, Klaviyo and Salesforce Marketing Cloud between them take more than half of email-platform moves. The companies moving to Klaviyo typically have a few hundred employees, those moving to Braze nearer two thousand, and those moving to Salesforce Marketing Cloud are among the largest companies in the set. That describes the companies choosing each tool; it does not show that size alone decided, and integrations, requirements, budgets and circumstances may matter too. Klaviyo and Salesforce Marketing Cloud take shares broadly in line with their matched benchmarks, while Braze’s share is much higher; the comparison adjusts for size and Shopify use, not for whatever else explains the choices. One buyer explained the Klaviyo choice in the same terms the commerce buyers use for Shopify: “Klaviyo is just kind of like the industry standard with Shopify stores.” For how the stack shifts with company size, see how company size shapes the stack.
The destinations that outrun the market
Several products appear more often among completed destinations than in the matched benchmark. Braze is the clearest: about 22% of observed email-platform moves against a 7% benchmark, roughly three times, and the gap holds when the moves are resampled by company and stays large against all companies rather than similar ones. Sigma shows the same direction in BI, with about one move in six while running in only a few percent of similar companies’ stacks. Webflow in CMS and Constructor in site search also sit above their benchmarks, but on fewer moves, so those gaps are less stable. These identify products taking a disproportionate share of the moves recorded here; they do not establish market-wide growth or better outcomes.
These stand out because they appear more often among recorded moves than their presence in comparable stacks suggests, a different signal from simply being common. It shows where migration activity in this sample concentrates relative to the benchmark, not why buyers chose these tools, whether the moves worked, or how buyers rate the tools afterwards.
Want your own stack read the same way?
Get mine →The counter-current: some departures have no destination
Every share on this page counts only moves that ended on a named tool. Plenty of departures do not. In several categories a company leaving a tool builds its own, hands the work to an agency, or simply stops, and those exits never appear in a split of destinations. The category pages count them where the interviews allow, for personalization engines, social media tools and attribution tools among others. A scattered split of destinations and a high rate of no destination at all are different findings, and a category can have both.
What this means if you are about to switch
Our recommendations, not practices buyers describe: they are implications of the patterns above. A split of destinations helps identify alternatives to investigate, not which product fits best or which move will succeed. Four questions, depending on where your category sits.
- Is one destination especially common among companies like yours? Shopify dominates the commerce moves recorded here, and Gorgias is the leading helpdesk destination among switchers who often run Shopify stores. Check whether you resemble those buyers in size, commerce setup, technical needs and operating model; a common destination is a relevant candidate, not an automatic pick. The largest companies leaving commerce platforms in these interviews split between Shopify and Salesforce Commerce Cloud.
- If moves spread across many products, how will you build the shortlist? BI, CMS, site search and testing show dispersed destinations here. Use the products switchers chose to find candidates, then define requirements, technical constraints and an owner for the evaluation; with no dominant destination, the migration data alone says little about which vendor fits.
- Does an above-benchmark destination meet your needs? Braze and Sigma take more completed moves than their matched presence would suggest. That makes them worth investigating, not proof of better performance or successful implementations. Seek evidence from organizations with comparable needs, ideally ones that have run the replacement long enough to judge results.
- Is your current product being retired or losing support? Identify the functions, data and integrations to preserve, and the migration deadline. Google Optimize’s retirement was followed by several different choices here, so an announced shutdown does not name one successor; build the comparison around your requirements and transition risks.
What not to read into this
Three readings go further than the data. The first is that a share of moves is a market share or a churn rate. It is neither: it is the split of confirmed moves in these interviews, and the interviews are not a random sample of the market. The second is that convergence means the destination is better. Where switchers converge, they mostly land on what companies like them already run, and none of the shares here say whether a move worked out. The third is that the comparison point controls for everything. It matches on company size and on whether a company runs Shopify, not on budget, industry or team, so a destination can sit above its benchmark for reasons the comparison cannot see. The moves come from interviews held between 2022 and November 2026, most of them in 2025 and 2026, while the benchmark summarizes tool use among comparable interviewed companies rather than reconstructing the choices or installed base at the date of each move; adoption, capabilities and positioning change over time. Most categories have only a few dozen completed named moves, more in email, so read these as descriptive patterns, emphasizing large differences and broad shapes rather than small gaps.
Common questions
Where do companies go when they switch software?
It depends on the category. In Alium’s interviews, two in three companies that changed commerce platforms moved to Shopify, and more than four in ten that changed helpdesks moved to Gorgias. In email platforms, BI tools, CMS, reviews, site search and A/B testing, no single destination takes more than about a quarter of the moves, and switchers spread across many tools.
Why do so many ecommerce brands switch to Shopify?
Shopify is already the platform most similar companies run, which helps explain it. Shopify’s share of commerce-platform moves in these interviews, about two in three, is close to its share among companies of a similar size, so the concentration is broadly consistent with existing adoption rather than a sudden swing toward it. The fifth of switchers who moved to Salesforce Commerce Cloud were typically much larger companies.
Which software categories have no default replacement?
BI and dashboards, CMS, site search and A/B testing show the widest spread: the leading destination takes a quarter of moves or less, and the moves are more dispersed than their matched benchmarks. Reviews tools are spread out too, in line with a category whose adoption is itself spread. In testing, about a third of the moves followed Google Optimize’s 2023 shutdown, and they went to six different tools.
Does a popular switching destination mean it is the best choice?
No. A share of moves shows where switchers went, not whether the move worked or whether the tool suits a different company. Where switchers converge, the leading destination is the tool companies like them already run most. Where a destination sits well above its benchmark, as Braze does in email and Sigma in BI, that shows where these moves concentrate, not proof that it is better. Our recommendation, not a practice buyers describe, is to compare a destination with the companies that chose it before treating it as the obvious pick.
For why companies leave in the first place, see the category pages on helpdesks, email platforms, BI tools, CMS, site search, A/B testing and reviews. For how a shortlist forms when no destination dominates, see how software buyers find vendors.
Your stack, read by the buyers who've run it
Peer-powered: built from hundreds of verified buyer interviews, and fitted to the tools you already run. You get a shortlist for your stack and your next steps.
Get my stack readFree · no password · your answers are anonymized before they inform research like this.